After Understanding
September 12 – October 17, 2026
KOTARO NUKAGA Tennoz
KOTARO NUKAGA Tennoz is pleased to present ‘After Understanding’, a solo exhibition by Rhizomatiks, on view September 12 – October 17, 2026.
At the center of the exhibition is a polar-coordinate plotter that engraves a single continuous line into a rotating metal disc with a diamond stylus.*1 The line originates in a group of formulae connected to the work of the Indian mathematician Srinivasa Ramanujan(1887 – 1920), together with experimental formulae that Rhizomatiks has constructed on their basis. The distribution of the values obtained from these formulae is converted into the spacing of the line at each point on the disc, and is engraved into the metal in accordance with prescribed speed conditions. When a result appears in advance of its meaning or its explanation, what meaning do we give it, and where do we find its value? The exhibition brings that interval of time into being within the movement of machine and metal.
A disc turns. Across its surface, a diamond stylus engraves a single continuous line. Once cut, a groove cannot be erased, nor can it be revised by tracing back through a history of edits as one would with a digital image. What remains in the metal is the path the stylus has taken, held there as a scar.
The plotter converts the relations obtained by evaluating the formulae on the complex plane into a single continuous line on the surface of the metal.*2 Of the magnitude, phase, and rate of change read out from the formulae, those features that have been selected vary the spacing of the line as it advances from the outer edge toward the inner edge. Where the line runs, and in what order, is calculated in advance and converted into one continuous movement composed of the rotation of the disc and the travel of the stylus. The order in which the line is cut, and the time over which the machine moved, are left in the metal as traces that cannot be undone.*3
Among the group of formulae to which the work refers, one has a distinctive property. *4 Within a certain circle on the complex plane, its values can be computed. On the circle itself, however, the points at which a value is determined and the points at which it is not are distributed so closely that both occur within any interval, however small. The relation established inside cannot therefore be extended outward as it stands. The nearer one comes to the boundary, the finer, without limit, the variation in the computed values becomes.*5 The stylus, for its part, has a minimum spacing below which it cannot cut. The line engraved on a single metal disc is that unlimited variation, recorded at the finite spacing the machine is able to cut.
Given the formula behind it, the value at any single point can in principle be computed. Neither the rules of conversion nor the movement of the machine is concealed. Yet however closely the eye follows the engraved line, the formula that drew it and the distribution of its values cannot be read back. In this work, knowing the rule of a formula, seeing the results it computes, following the process by which they are converted into a single line, and looking at the finished disc are each a different experience.
A mathematical discovery can precede the understanding of what it means. The mock theta functions that Ramanujan set down in 1920 were given a modern theoretical position only in 2002, eighty-two years later.*6 Today, moreover, AI systems search through possibilities at a rate at which no person could examine them one by one, and carry the results forward into further computation and further inquiry.*7 What this work takes up is not the discovery of a new formula. It is the interval by which a result obtained from a formula arrives ahead of human understanding. That relation is engraved into metal through the movement of a machine, and the viewer sees the process by which a line comes into being before grasping what it means.
At the end of the 1960s, the critic Jack Burnham advanced the notion of “systems esthetics”, which understands the work of art not as a finished object but as a system operating in time and space.*8 This work, too — presenting as itself not only the finished disc but the process by which a formula, passing through the movement of a machine, is converted into a line — can be seen as standing within that lineage.
Rhizomatiks has consistently included in its works not only the image but the data, the models, the apparatus, and the environment that produce it, opening the conditions of generation to the audience.*9 ‘After Understanding’ carries that practice forward, and advances to a point at which disclosing a process does not necessarily bring about an understanding of it.
The line is already cut, its order already fixed, and the metal that has been removed does not return. What the viewer sees is only the trace of a line coursing across the disc in every direction. ‘After Understanding’ asks how, when a result appears in advance of understanding, we are to give it meaning and take it upon ourselves.
1. Polar coordinates describe a position not as a pair of x- and y-values but as a distance from a center together with an angle. In this work, the rotation of the disc corresponds to the angle, and the radial travel of the stylus to the distance from the center.
2. The complex plane represents numbers as points on a plane. With the real part on the horizontal axis and the imaginary part on the vertical axis, the relations a formula generates can be grasped as an extension across a plane.
3. The polar-coordinate planner takes a predetermined line trajectory and computes the machine’s motion and the time it requires on the basis of velocity and acceleration conditions.
4. Rhizomatiks’ production materials list the Rogers–Ramanujan continued fraction, the mock theta functions, Ramanujan’s tau function, the Dedekind eta function, the generating function for the partition function, and experimental formulae constructed for this work.
5. The Rogers–Ramanujan continued fraction is meromorphic inside the unit disc, and the unit circle is a natural boundary. On the circle, the points at which the continued fraction converges and the points at which it diverges are both dense. J. Mc Laughlin and D. Bowman, “On the Divergence of the Rogers-Ramanujan Continued Fraction on the Unit Circle,” arXiv:math/0107043, https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0107043v2(accessed August 30, 2026).
6. In 2002, the doctoral thesis of Sander Zwegers showed that the mock theta functions can be understood as the holomorphic parts of harmonic weak Maass forms of weight 1/2. W. Duke, “Almost a Century of Answering the Question: What is a Mock Theta Function?,” https://www.math.ucla.edu/~wdduke/preprints/mocktheta.pdf / M. Griffin, K. Ono, and L. Rolen, “Ramanujan’s mock theta functions,” PNAS, https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1300345110(both accessed August 30, 2026).
7. In July 2026, prompted by a question from Akhil Mathew, Levent Alpöge announced an explicit three-dimensional counterexample to the Jacobian conjecture, obtained in the course of work with the AI system Claude Fable. On the same day, a formal proof in the proof assistant Lean and an independent formal verification in Isabelle/HOL were made public. In August of the same year, OpenAI announced that an internal version of its next major model, Astra, had solved or substantially advanced ten longstanding open problems in mathematics and theoretical computer science. https://isa-afp.org/entries/Jacobian_Counterexample.html / https://openai.com/index/ten-advances-in-mathematics/(both accessed August 30, 2026)
8. Jack Burnham, “Systems Esthetics,” Artforum, vol. 7, no. 1, September 1968, pp. 30–35, https://www.artforum.com/features/systems-esthetics-201372/(accessed August 30, 2026).
9. For ‘Rhizomatiks Beyond Perception’ in 2024, Rhizomatiks developed Beyond Perception Model, an image-generating AI model independent of existing foundation models, trained on approximately 170,000 images extracted from footage to which Rhizomatiks itself holds the copyright. In recursive, of the same year, the outputs of the AI were returned into the training process, while the visitors captured by the camera and the surrounding environment were drawn into that circulation as well. Writing on recursive, Yuko Hasegawa observed that what is exhibited is “not only the goal of the generated image, but how its process is to be shown,” and identified behind this “Rhizomatiks’ sensitivity to information processing, and its aesthetics”(translated from the Japanese). ‘Rhizomatiks Beyond Perception’, KOTARO NUKAGA, June 29 – October 14, 2024. https://kotaronukaga.com/en/exhibition/rhizomatiks-beyond-perception/ / Rhizomatiks, recursive, 2024. https://rhizomatiks.com/en/work/recursive/
ARTIST
DATE
September 12 – October 17, 2026 11:30 – 18:00(Tue – Sat) *Closed on Sun, Mon and Public Holidays *Open on September 13, October 11 and October 12 Opening Reception: September 12, 2026 16:00 – 18:00
VENUE